HomeLend Mortgage Blog

How to Compare Mortgage Rates Without Damaging Your Credit Score

Written by HomeLend | Nov 29, 2024 3:30:00 PM

When shopping for a mortgage, comparing rates from multiple lenders is crucial to finding the best deal. However, many homebuyers worry that multiple credit inquiries could hurt their credit score. The good news? You can shop for a mortgage while minimizing or avoiding any negative impact on your credit. Here’s how to navigate the mortgage shopping process while protecting your credit score.

1. Understand How Credit Checks Affect Your Score

When you apply for a mortgage, lenders typically perform a hard inquiry to review your credit history. While hard inquiries can slightly lower your credit score, they’re usually only a minor factor in your overall credit health.

Key Facts:

  • Soft Inquiries: Checking your own credit or prequalification by lenders doesn’t affect your credit score.

  • Hard Inquiries: Triggered when you submit a formal application for a loan. Multiple hard inquiries in a short period are treated as one if within the rate-shopping window (see below).

2. Use the Rate Shopping Window to Your Advantage

Credit scoring models like FICO and Vantage Score allow borrowers to shop for mortgage rates within a specific timeframe without multiple inquiries significantly affecting their score. During this window, all mortgage-related hard inquiries are treated as a single inquiry.

  • FICO Window: 14 to 45 days, depending on the version used by the lender.

  • Vantage Score Window: 14 days.

Tip: Plan to complete your mortgage shopping within a two-week period to maximize this benefit.

3. Start with Prequalification

Prequalification is a preliminary assessment where lenders estimate how much you may be eligible to borrow based on the financial information you provide. This process typically involves a soft inquiry, meaning it won’t affect your credit score.

Why Prequalification Helps:

  • Allows you to understand potential loan terms without formal credit checks.

  • Gives a sense of which lenders align with your needs before you commit to an application.

4. Research Lenders and Rates Before Applying

Before submitting applications, invest time in researching lenders to narrow down your options. By doing your homework upfront, you can limit the number of hard inquiries needed during the shopping process.

Steps to Research Lenders:

  1. Use Online Tools: Many websites allow you to compare rates from different lenders without affecting your credit.

  2. Read Reviews: Look for feedback on customer service, responsiveness, and transparency.

  3. Contact Lenders: Ask about their loan programs and whether they offer prequalification or preapproval with a soft inquiry.

5. Focus on Fixed vs. Variable Rates

When comparing mortgage options, one of the key decisions is whether to choose a fixed-rate or adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM). Each comes with its benefits, and understanding these differences can help you refine your search and avoid unnecessary applications.

  • Fixed-Rate Mortgages: Provide predictable monthly payments but may start with higher rates.

  • Adjustable-Rate Mortgages (ARMs): Offer lower initial rates that adjust periodically based on market conditions, often tied to the prime rate.

6. Monitor Your Credit Before and During the Process

Maintaining good credit habits before and during the mortgage shopping process is essential. Even small changes to your credit profile can affect your eligibility and the rates you’re offered.

Steps to Monitor Your Credit:

  • Review Your Credit Report: Check for errors or inaccuracies on your credit report and dispute them if needed.

  • Avoid New Credit Accounts: Hold off on applying for other loans or credit cards until after your mortgage is secured.

  • Pay Down Balances: Reducing your credit card balances can improve your debt-to-income ratio and overall creditworthiness.

7. Consider Working with a Mortgage Broker

Mortgage brokers can simplify the rate shopping process by connecting you with multiple lenders without requiring you to apply individually at each one. This approach may limit the number of hard inquiries on your credit.

Benefits of a Mortgage Broker:

  • Access to a wide network of lenders.

  • Expert guidance to find the best loan terms.

  • Potentially fewer credit inquiries compared to applying on your own.

Things to Keep in Mind:

  • Brokers may charge fees for their services, so clarify costs upfront.

8. Strategize for Refinancing

If you’re shopping for a mortgage as part of a refinance, the same principles apply. Compare rates within a short time frame, focus on lenders with favorable terms, and monitor your credit to ensure eligibility.

Additional Refinancing Tip:
Consider cash-out refinancing options or rate-and-term refinancing based on your financial goals.

Conclusion

Shopping for a mortgage doesn’t have to hurt your credit score. By understanding how credit inquiries work, leveraging rate-shopping windows, and focusing on prequalification, you can compare lenders with confidence. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or refinancing your current loan, following these steps will help you secure the best mortgage deal while maintaining a strong credit profile.